Click to see the full-size image
Written by Ahmed Adel, Cairo-based geopolitics and political economy researcher
The Wall Street Journal reported that Western politicians have begun speculating about Kiev’s preparations for a possible new counteroffensive next spring. The media outlet quoted diplomats saying that the US and other Western officials hoped the Ukrainian military’s much-vaunted summer counteroffensive, initially scheduled for the spring, would succeed and help force Russia to negotiate this winter – but this did not occur. Thus, the focus is now moving to next year.
The cited diplomats also assessed that Western military strategists and politicians have already begun to think about a possible Ukrainian offensive in the spring of 2024, suggesting that there are still definitely hardcore elements in Western decision-making centres that want the conflict to continue. It is especially questionable how Ukraine will be able to build a brand-new army while, at the same time, Russia continues to build its defences and offensive capabilities.
The Ukrainian counteroffensive began on June 4 in the southern regions of Donetsk, Artyomovsk (Bakhmut) and Zaporozhye. The attempts by Ukrainian troops to pierce the first Russian line of defence have catastrophically failed, leading to thousands of Ukrainian casualties, shattered morale, and a destroyed army. This enormous cost led to only about 10 miles in two areas being captured by Ukrainian forces, all in a dead zone in territory that Russia was willing to sacrifice when considering the enemy still had not even reached the first line of defence.
Kiev’s failures in the counteroffensive were the indecision of Western allies and, personally, of US President Joe Biden, former US National Security Adviser John Bolton said in an article in The Wall Street Journal.
According to Bolton, “inability to achieve major advances is the natural result of a U.S. strategy aimed only at staving off Russian conquest.”
At the same time, Bolton said the constant debate in the West over the desirability of arms supplies to Ukraine and Moscow’s nuclear power has engendered a “paralysing caution” in European capitals. He stressed that the West, especially Washington, needed to “radically” rethink its sanctions policy to put pressure on Russia.
“Theories about price caps on Russian oil have failed, and Western sanctions generally remain piecemeal and seriously underenforced,” he said, adding: “Proclaiming sanctions is great PR, but enforcement is hard, tedious and necessarily done clandestinely where possible.”
Given the catastrophic failure of the 2023 counteroffensive, there is little suggestion that 2024 will be better since Ukraine will need several years to rebuild its military capabilities following its destruction by Russian forces. While some elements of Western leadership discuss a 2023 counteroffensive, reports have emerged that thousands of Ukrainians paid high bribes to corrupt army recruiters to avoid being conscripted amid Russia’s special military operation in Ukraine.
According to reports, 20,000 Ukrainian citizens were prevented from leaving the country following an order by President Volodymyr Zelensky regarding regional recruiting chiefs. The cost of bribes differs across Ukraine, with many draft defectors asked to pay $6,000 for a medical certificate that exempts them from military service.
The FT mentioned Yevgeny Borisov, head of the regional recruiting centre in Odessa, who was arrested in July after being accused of receiving more than $5 million in bribes to approve exemptions, helping hundreds of men, and possibly thousands, who paid between US$2,000 and $10,000 per person. Ukrainian investigators said Borisov used most of the ill-gotten money to buy a €4.2m home in Spain in December 2022 and travel abroad to holiday, including in Seychelles.
According to the British newspaper, after Zelensky ordered the dismissal of all regional army recruitment chiefs suspected of being involved in corruption schemes, 13,600 Ukrainians were caught trying to enter neighbouring countries without going through official checkpoints. Another 6,100 were detained when trying to use false documents at regular border crossings.
These events, which are being reported during the failed Kiev counteroffensive, not only point to an issue of corruption in the Ukrainian military but also highlight recruitment issues. This again suggests that ideas of another counteroffensive in 2024 are fanciful at best.
In addition, Ukraine does not have air superiority. Modern warfare can only be won with air superiority, but this is especially prioritised in US military doctrine, on which the much-vaunted counteroffensive relied despite not having air superiority. As Russia has air superiority, something it will maintain over the course of this war, it dominates the sky and destroys command control systems, missile emplacements, and troop convoys.
Given that willingness, as well reported in Western media, to support Ukraine financially endlessly is diminishing in the West, in addition to recruitment issues and being unable to achieve air superiority, ideas of a major Ukrainian counteroffensive in 2024 cannot be taken seriously. Ukraine’s army has been devastated and is unlikely to recover during the war.
speech nyc april 4 1967 by martin luther king answers all the questions about right now.
se aseamana cu politicienii romani
cred ca joaca solitaire la anul
ru state propagandist, armen gasparyan, openly on ru tv demands to establish permanent “order of satan” in russia. so now it is clear for everybody to see who the russians are fighting for, and why jewtin chose 666 (24.f.2022) as date for the start of his war. see: http://rlu.ru/3tcrm
should be a hoot seeing nato when it’s ready to officially declare war walk itself into the “meat grinder”…
thank you russia for doing the gene pool a service by eliminating those who would continue to fuck with you given the results over the past 9 years… and when it comes timepicking and choosing which territories they will be forced to leave in order to go all in on a russian “invasion”…
… and should those f-16s be stupid enough to cross the eastern shoals of russia as the last suicide run… those rs-28s… rsm-56s… and hypersonic nuclear tipped spears of death will eliminate the rest of the western “problem” for good!
‘thank you russia for doing the gene pool a service’
in what way? by killing thousands of working class slavic conscripts while releasing azov nazis to bomb donbass civilians, torture rf soldiers & work for uk’s mi6 in africa? be honest, russia’s smo has been a dog’s breakfast so far.
what only occurs when an ex comedian who use to play pianos in high heels with his “pecker” is anointed as the junta leader of an “installed” $$ soros .gov!…
ask me what ukraine would look like today had the west not forced an “orange revolution” and coup on the legitimate yanukovitch government?…
ukr was a puppet usa state years before zebedee. even dating the demise of ukraine from vicky’s 2014 coup (preparation started 65 years before btw), russia’s response was, to say the least, tepid. putin looked the other way for years as russian speakers were slaughtered by nazis before z pushed his luck (demanding nato nukes 19 feb 2022). only then did putin finally notice 14,000 donbass corpses.
ps: what ‘gene pool’ do you think is really being wiped out?
“putin looked the other way for years as russian speakers were slaughtered by nazis before z pushed his luck (demanding nato nukes 19 feb 2022). only then did putin finally notice 14,000 donbass corpses.”…
not going to “+” you for that statement, but you are most definitely correct. especially when ambassador churkin cried “sos” when yanukovitch begged russia for military support…
‘…in territory that russia was willing to sacrifice…’
in donbass actually, which rus pledged to rid of ukronazis.
‘…had not even reached the first line of defence.’
lines set up deep in donetsk to protect, err, crimea not donbass.
another c/o because nato knows rus will still not have fulfilled the smo pledges by 2024 or ’25 or ’26…
16.08.23. ukranazis:” -we are winning against the orcs”. nato:” -we will give you membership if you capitulate the occupied regions”. 😆😆😆
so, where is the ukraine going to find the manpower to fight this new offensive with? they’re already scraping the bottom of the barrel now. during the battle for berlin in 1945 the ss had special groups, the ‘greiff’ commandos, hunting down every man in berlin to fight. the ukrainian counterparts are already doing this. are they now going into houses too? or be allowed into the eu to hunt among the ukrainian diaspora?
hunting in the eu i doubt, but for raid into houses they are already sending their “feldjäger”, there are many videos about it on telegram. in one of the videos the little boy cries: “dad, where are they taking you?”. well, little boy , i hate to say that, but the nazis are taking your dad to the cemetery.
and when they make lvov the nazi capital after donating kiev to russia, russia will just bomb lvovite scum back into their burrows, “their children will grow up in cellars.” hahahahaha
maybe they plan, but how to do this? 1. nato reserve stocks are running dry and for example germans now sending to ukros 60 year old marder and leo1 tanks because they have nothing better left over. 2. reports says ukros grabbing now 18+ and 45+ from the streets, because all men between are dead or wounded now, so what will they do then, all ages from 16-65 like german volkssturm?